Knowledge makes us Unhappy.

The phrase, “Knowledge is power” is a phrase that is commonly used in all institutions of life, and is one that’s value is often misunderstood. The quote is true, knowing things does allow us to make more informed decisions that will positively impact our life, and that could very easily be considered a form of power. However, this quote seems to always be used to drive home the belief that having knowledge is an objectively good thing, and the negative aspects of having knowledge are never considered. Knowledge has undoubtedly been what’s allowed humanity to push forward and survive for millions of years, but these triumphs have made us largely uninterested what negative aspects knowledge may have on the individual who possesses it. Sure, phrases like “Ignorance is bliss” and the infamous troubled genius stereotype do explore how possessing knowledge can be a bad thing, but they fail to establish a direct link between having knowledge and being unhappy.

Sarah Lindberg in her article titled, “Is Watching the News bad for Mental Health” examines the relationship between news consumption and mental health. She explains how the emotional impact of consuming negative news can lead to heightened feelings on depression and anxiety. The fact that consuming a lot of news is bad for our mental health is a well-documented and unsurprising fact at this point, but how does it relate to negative effects of possessing knowledge? When we watch the news, we are gaining knowledge on current events, and that knowledge makes us think about what we can do about it. For example, if someone watches a story on a mass shooting, that knowledge could make them want to go to a protest, or fundraise for a politician who promises to implement a solution to the issue. In other words, the knowledge they gained from watching the news gave them the power to make a change, which is great for society as a whole. But how does that effect the person on a personal level? Not only were they subjected to the horrors of the original news story, but now they are spending their time thinking about a morbid subject. It would be a lot easier for this person to have never saw the news story in the first place.

One argument against the idea that knowledge causes unhappiness could be that the knowledge isn’t whats causing the unhappiness, but the actions we take as a result of the knowledge is. Knowledge in itself though can absolutely be what causes unhappiness. For example if someone has cancer, getting a diagnosis from a doctor is the best thing for their physical health because now they can start treating the cancer and getting better. This isn’t how cancer patients tend to view the diagnosis though. According to information published by the ADAA, “After diagnosis, 40 percent of cancer patients report developing significant distress that can include serious worry, panic attacks, depression, and PTSD, or posttraumatic stress disorder.” What’s key to focus on here is that these symptoms are occurring after the initial diagnosis, not after the extensive treatment of the patient that would undoubtedly negative impact their mental health as well. The knowledge of having an awful, life threatening disease, despite that knowledge being the best thing for them, causes the patients to become more unhappy. And this reaction is completely understandable, but it also proves how knowledge can be negative.

While the previously mentioned examples are certainly extreme examples, we can even see examples of knowledge creating a sense of disappointment in our daily lives. Many people use honey as a way to sweeten whatever they are consuming, thinking that its a healthier alternative to sugar. In reality, consuming honey is pretty much the exact same as consuming sugar, with the only difference being that honey is sweeter, so you’ll use less of it. The people who have been slathering their pastries and beverages in honey would probably be pretty upset to learnt that they’ve essentially been consuming pure sugar for years. Once again, its pretty safe to assume that they’d rather not learned this fact at all. After all, they want whatever they’re eating or drinking to be sweet enough. Similarly, those who take melatonin before bed would probably be upset to hear that daily intake of the supplement actually damages their quality of sleep in the long run. In both of these cases, the person would be able to make an informed decision about how they want to change the way that they are living, and this is a good thing! But despite this, the immediate psychological effects that this knowledge gives us tend to be negative most of the time.

There is a time and a place for people to want to learn things. When people go out and learn things about a subject that they choose to study in college, chances are that they will be less likely to develop these unwanted, negative thoughts. When we learn things in an unexpected or forced manner, these negative feelings are much more likely to occur. So if forced knowledge makes us unhappy, then how do we go about teaching kids important subjects in school? Forcing kids to learn about more specific and concrete subjects, like taxes and nutrition for example, would only seem to create a lot of unhappy students, which would benefit nobody. It can be hard to accept that not teaching children about different subjects wouldn’t be beneficial to them, but if we know that this forced knowledge would make them unhappy, then shouldn’t we look in other places to get them these skills? Even if knowledge is making us unhappy, the positive aspects of having a knowledgable population certainly outweigh the negatives of having slightly more unhappy individuals. After all, possessing knowledge doesn’t automatically usher someone into a deep depression. It simply creates some unwanted feelings that could ultimately, if not checked, lead someone to be generally unhappy.

Refrences

“Is Watching the News Bad for Mental Health?” Verywell Mind, https://www.verywellmind.com/is-watching-the-news-bad-for-mental-health-4802320. Accessed 5 Nov. 2023.

Serious, Chronic, or Terminal Illnesses – Tips for Patients and Caregivers | Anxiety and Depression Association of America, ADAA. https://adaa.org/serious-chronic-or-terminal-illnesses#:~:text=People%20who%20have%20serious%2C%20chronic,for%20experiencing%20anxiety%20and%20depression. Accessed 5 Nov. 2023.