Proposal+5-sixers103

For my research paper I will be taking a further look into speeding throughout neighborhoods. I want to get in-depth about the short term and long term affects of speeding and the possible outcomes that could be possible. I will be incorporating some real life examples that will allow for someone reading to be able to understand my topic a lot clearer. I am going to argue that speeding through neighborhoods is way too common and that the speed limit should be adjusted in all neighborhoods. I also want to argue how police officers really don’t pay much attention to speeding in neighborhoods and that there should be a police presence watching at all times.

Sources:

1. 5  Ways To Stop Speeding In Your Neighborhood

URL: https://homealarmreport.com/safety/5-ways-stop-speeding/

  • Background: This article gives five examples on how speeding could be prevented in neighborhoods. It talks about speed bumps, types of parking, police assistance, video surveillance, and forming a petition. The author gives insight on a little bit of each way explaining how it could be beneficial.
  • How I intend to use it: I will be using this article to enhance how these five ways can stop speeding and using real life examples to put with the five ways.

2. The Dangers Of Speeding Through Neighborhoods 

URL: https://sanchezandpinon.com/the-dangers-of-speeding-through-neighborhoods/

  • Background: This article is like buried treasure, for the fact that it gives so much information, statistics, and even an example of how speeding affected a neighborhood. The author goes in depth about multiple ways that as a neighborhood you can try to prevent speeding. 
  • How I intend to use it: I intend to use the statistics while giving credit to the author and put my own opinion on the topics the author talked about throughout the article like the pet aspect.

3. How Can I Slow Down Traffic On My Street/Neighborhood

URL: https://blog.ioby.org/how-can-i-slow-down-traffic-on-my-street/

  • Background: This article is really more about the “speaking up” aspect. The author really gets into talking to local government about ways that could help control speeding. For each example the author gives a multistep plan that will allow you to achieve success. 
  • How I intend to use it: I will focus on more of the speaking up part of this article to really understand what it will definitely take to get the local government to finally show some care about speeding through neighborhoods.

4. Speeding In Residential Areas: A Matter Of Life And Death

URL: https://theberkshireedge.com/speeding-in-residential-neighborhoods-a-matter-of-life-and-death/

  • Background: This article is basically talking about a real life example of a group of people were using posters to get the attention of the town about neighborhood speeding. It goes in depth of what the people wanted to be done and how the meeting between the town manager and the board went down. It gives multiple perspectives on the topic and provides a ton of information/examples that could really benefit my argument 
  • How I intend to use it: I want to pick this article apart and use statements from the board meeting to further my argument while at the same time using bits and pieces of the examples provided throughout the article.

5. Dangers Of Speeding In A Residential Neighborhood

URL: https://www.bottlingerlaw.com/blog/dangers-of-speeding-in-a-residential-neighborhood/

  • Background: This article talks about the affects of speeding and what it could mean for you as the driver. It goes in depth about the penalties that a person may receive for speeding. The author really focuses on the law side of speeding, warning drivers what could happen if you decide to speed in a neighborhood.
  • How I intend to use it: I will be able to incorporate the law side into my argument which will give my argument a stronger position. I want to also incorporate the law side into my examples stating what a certain situation can cause for not only the driver but the people living in the neighborhood. 
This entry was posted in Proposal+5, sixers103. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Proposal+5-sixers103

  1. davidbdale says:

    You’re making a start here, Sixers, on a topic I would never have imagined a student would propose, so that’s refreshing. You’re going to need some actual sources though. What you have here are good ways to get you thinking but nothing that qualifies as a legitimate source for an academic paper. Three of your five are actually commercial sites (2 for law firms, one for a home security company that is clearly an advertisement for their security camera).

    As an example of how to proceed, you say about your “Sanchez and Pinon” article that you’re going to cite their statistics. It’s a useful idea, but the statistics are not from Sanchez and Pinon. They link you to statistics from the National Highway Traffic Safety Association. THAT’s your source. You may find that S&P have been scrupulous in their appropriating of the work of the NHTSA. On the other hand, you may discover that they’ve cherry-picked some details or taken them out of context to suit their commercial needs. Your job is to vet those numbers back to the original.

    I haven’t seen anything in your material so far that actually validates the effectiveness of the strategies you recommend. Before you try to persuade anyone that painting murals on the street to slow down speeders by interesting them in art, you might want to quantify that claim. Just sayin’.

    I did a one-minute search on Google Scholar for “effective traffic management reduce speeding” (but not in quotation marks), and came up with some very promising results:

    1. “Differential effects of traffic sign stimuli upon speeding in school zones following a traffic light interruption”
    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0001457515301020

    2. From the Institute of Traffic Engineers: “ITE traffic calming definition”
    https://search.proquest.com/docview/224878813?pq-origsite=gscholar

    3. From the Transportation Research Record: “Alternatives to Enforcement in Modifying
    the Speeding Behavior of Drivers”

    Click to access 1111-014.pdf

    Each of these sources has something important to say about the psychology of drivers who speed and ways to convince them to slow down. Give them a chance. They may or may not contain easy answers to complex questions, but they’ll help you consider WHY some solutions might be smarter than others.

    As I think I said to you about your Hypothesis, the notion that cops are going to patrol the residential neighborhoods is much less likely than that towns will install cameras that can issue tickets automatically. On Collings Avenue near the Collingswood High School, I see a sign like this fairly often:

    Here’s the kind I expect to see next:

    And here’s an article from Toronto about a town that will start issuing tickets automatically without officer interaction.
    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/toronto-photo-radar-cameras-scannable-1.5397516

    That should REALLY cut down on speeding.

    Questions?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s