Proposal +5 – ConfusedPinky

Exploring the Impact of Cluster B Personality Disorders on Relationship Perception and success Among Young Adults

Proposal:

In today’s diverse society, relationships play a crucial role in shaping individuals’ lives, influencing their emotional well-being, and overall happiness. For young adults, navigating the complex landscape of relationships can be both intriguing and challenging. One intriguing aspect of interpersonal dynamics is the influence of personality disorders, particular Cluster B personality disorders, on how individuals perceive and engage in relationships. This research aims to delve into the perceptual differences among young adults diagnosed with Cluster B personality disorders and how these differences may affect the success of their relationships

Background: 

Cluster B personality disorders, including borderline, antisocial, histrionic, and narcissistic personality disorders, are characterized by dramatic, emotional, or erratic behavior. Research suggests that individuals with these disorders often face challenges in forming and maintaining healthy relationships. Understanding the perceptual disparities related to these disorders is vital, especially among young adults who are in the process of forming long term relationships and families.

Resources:

Assessing Young Adults’ Beliefs Regarding the Importance of Romantic Relationships

Background: The study introduces the brief Measure of Relationship importance, a tool designed to delve into the evolving landscape of young adult’s attitudes concerning romantic relationships taking on increasing importance, shaping their identities, emotional experiences, and future aspirations. This period is marked by significant developmental changes, including the exploration of intimate relationships, self-discovery, and the establishment of long-term commitments. 

How I plan to use it: In understanding the intricacies of young adult romantic relationships, the BReif measure of Relationship importance provides a vital base line. It defines the spectrum of relationship attitudes, distinguishing between desire and dismissal. For typical young adults, romantic relationships signify significant components, involving desires for fulfillment and satisfaction. In contrast, individuals diagnosed with Cluster B personality disorders might exhibit a range of attitudes, potentially leaning towards intense desire or dismissal, influenced by their disorder-related behaviors and emotional experiences. By using the measure as a benchmark, we can discern the distinctive relationship attitudes between two groups, illuminating the nuanced differences that influence the experiences and outcomes in their romantic relationships.

Narcissism and Romantic Relationships

Background:The study delves into the intricate dynamics of romantic relationships involving narcissistic individuals, a subset of Cluster B personality disorders. Narcissism is characterized by grandiosity, a lick of empathy, and a constant need for admiration. Understanding the impact of narcissistic traits on romantic relationships is vital, as these individuals often display self-centered behaviors that can strain interpersonal connections. The study explores whether there is a correlation between narcissism and relationship satisfaction, shedding light on the challenges faced by partners in these relationships.

How I plan to use it: This study serves as a valuable background to understand the specific traits associated with narcissism in romantic relationships. By delving into the traits of grandiose, lacking empathy, and the pursuit of admiration, I can also analyze how these behaviors manifest within intimate partnerships. This understanding is crucial for deciphering the unique dynamics of relationships involving narcissistic individuals.

Classification of Personality Disorders

Background: This study investigates the personality traits of psychiatric patients, specifically focusing on those diagnosed with personality disorders compared to patients with other psychiatric diagnoses. The research employs factor analysis and cluster analysis to identify patterns within these personality traits. The findings suggest that personality disorders might differ only in degree from the personalities of other psychiatric patients, implying potential similarities in underlying traits across psychiatric diagnoses.

How I plan to use it: This study challenges the conventional classification of personality disorders. By highlighting the similarities in personality traits between patients with personality disorders and those with  other psychiatric diagnoses, it questions the current classification system’s complexity. I intend to use this information to critically evaluate classification models, particularly concerning Cluster B personality disorders. This study’s findings could influence how these disorders are categorized and understood in relation to other psychiatric conditions.

Discrepancy in Personality Perception is Related to Relationship Satisfaction

Background: This study investigates the disparities in how individuals perceive their own personality traits, how their partners perceive these traits, and how individuals perceive their partner’s traits in intimate couples. It explores these discrepancies with the framework of the Big Five personality traits ( Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism) and their influence on relationship satisfaction. This research is grounded in the context of the Swiss study “ OcDevelopment in Personality,” focusing on a study group of 216 heterosexual couples.

How I plan to use it:This study’s exploration of discrepancies in self- and partner- perceptions offers a valuable lens to examine the perceptual differences prevalent in relationships involving individuals with Cluster B personality disorders. By understanding these disparities I aim to analyze how individuals with Cluster B disorders perceive themselves, how these perceptions impact relationship dynamics. This understanding will enable a nuances exploration of the challenges stemming from distorted self-perceptions and their consequences for relationship satisfaction. 

Romantic relationship dysfunction in borderline personality disorder—a naturalistic approach to trustworthiness perception.

Background: This study delves into the intricacies of interpersonal thirst within romantic relationships involving individuals diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). Interpersonal trust is a fundamental component of close relationships, yet its dynamics, especially in the context of BPD, have been understudied. BPD patients often face challenges in maintaining stable interpersonal relationships due to their emotional patients often face challenges in maintaining stable interpersonal relationships due to their emotional instability and impulsivity. Understanding how trustworthiness perception is influenced by relationship-threatening situations critical to comprehending the social dysfunction experienced by individuals with BPD.
How I plan to use it: The study mentions perceived tenderness in the relationship as a protective factor. I plan to explore this aspect further in the context of Cluster B personality disorders. How do positive emotional experiences and perceptions of tenderness impact trustworthiness perception for individuals with BPD? Understanding these protective factors can provide insights into potential interventions or support systems that can enhance relationship stability for individuals with Cluster B disorders.

This entry was posted in Proposal+5. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Proposal +5 – ConfusedPinky

  1. davidbdale's avatar davidbdale says:

    Not quite sure what to make of this vague terminology, Pinky.

    how individuals perceive and engage in relationships. This research aims to delve into the perceptual differences among young adults diagnosed with Cluster B personality disorders and how these differences may affect the success of their relationships

    THIS I UNDERSTAND, AND I SEE HOW CLUSTER B MIGHT GREATLY IMPEDE SUCCESSFUL INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS:

    Cluster B personality disorders, including borderline, antisocial, histrionic, and narcissistic personality disorders, are characterized by dramatic, emotional, or erratic behavior.

    Not sure I understand WHAT the the Brief Measure of Relationship Importance is, exactly. Is it a survey of Cluster B subjects’ SUBJECTIVE APPRAISAL of what’s important to them in relationships?

    I don’t think your Plan to Use It expands much on your Backgrounder for the Narcissism source, Confused Pinky, but I’m confident that the “correlation between narcissism and relationship satisfaction” is that a narcissist is only satisfied in a relationship with an adoring fan. And that’s no guarantee the relationship will work out for BOTH parties.

    Then there’s this from the Classification source:
    “The findings suggest that personality disorders might differ only in degree from the personalities of other psychiatric patients, implying potential similarities in underlying traits across psychiatric diagnoses.”
    —I’d like to suggest that also “personality disorders might differ only in degree from the personalities of most average human beings.” We all have “borderline, antisocial, histrionic, and narcissistic” tendencies to a degree. Our borderlines are just in different parts of the spectrum. Right?

    This is just a typo, right?: OcDevelopment
    Regarding the Discrepancy source, I’d like to observe that the flavors of Cluster B wouldn’t exist if everybody understood and evaluated themselves without distortion or discrepancy.

    And finally, regarding the Interpersonal Relationships source, you’ve really lost me.
    —Is it really about interpersonal thirst? Or is that a typo of trust?
    —Then there’s THIS insane sentence that eats its own tail:

    BPD patients often face challenges in maintaining stable interpersonal relationships due to their emotional patients often face challenges in maintaining stable interpersonal relationships due to their emotional instability and impulsivity.

    —And I can’t tell from either paragraph whether expressed or perceived, given or received tenderness is considered beneficial to the borderline partner in the relationship or whether it’s suspected of being insincere, or a threat, or what.

    Remember, this post gets expanded with whatever other sources you consult. Be sure to add new material as you gather it. When it’s complete, we’ll change the name of the post to “Annotated Bibliography” and it will go right into your Portfolio.

    Provisionally graded. Revisions are pretty much required for this post-in-progress, and Regrades will happen every time I become aware of an update, including AFTER it goes into your Portfolio.

Leave a reply to davidbdale Cancel reply